How to Compare Supplier Quotes for Furniture and Finishes
· 7 min read
To compare supplier quotes fairly, send every supplier the same brief, convert each answer to one landed cost for the same quantity, and then set lead time, payment terms and risks next to the price. The lowest unit price is rarely the cheapest offer once delivery, packaging, reserve and advance payments are counted. The method below works for furniture, joinery, tiles, flooring and other finishes.
Start with one identical brief
Quotes differ mostly because suppliers answer different questions. One includes delivery, another does not. One rounds up to whole boxes, another quotes the net area. If the brief is loose, you end up comparing assumptions instead of prices.
- Write the specification. Reference or SKU, dimensions, material, finish, colour, grade and quantity.
- State the quantity in purchasable units. For finishes, give the net area, the reserve for cutting and the package size. Example: 60 m² net plus a 10% reserve is 66 m². With 1.44 m² per box that is 45.83 boxes, so 46 boxes, or 66.24 m².
- Describe the delivery point. Address, floor, lift or no lift, who unloads, whether assembly is needed.
- Fix the reply format. Ask for unit price, total, delivery cost, lead time, price validity and payment terms as separate lines.
- Send the brief on the same day with one reply deadline. This keeps prices, stock and validity periods comparable.
Brief checklist
- Exact reference, finish and colour, with a sample or photo if there is any doubt
- Quantity in whole packages or pieces, with the reserve already included
- Delivery address and unloading conditions
- Whether assembly, installation or measurement is in scope
- Currency and whether prices are shown before or after tax
- Required date on site
Convert every quote to a landed cost
Landed cost is what the item really costs you once it stands at the site. It is the only figure that lets you compare a supplier with free delivery against one with a lower unit price.
- Convert all offers to one currency and make sure all prices are either before or after tax.
- Round the quantity up to whole packages or pieces, as the supplier will invoice it.
- Multiply by the unit price.
- Add delivery, unloading, packaging or crating, and any handling fees that are written in the quote.
- Apply only the discounts that are written in the quote, not the ones promised verbally.
- Add the costs the quote leaves out but you still have to cover, such as measurement or assembly by a third party.
Worked example
Example only: three suppliers quote the same porcelain tile for 46 boxes (66.24 m²). All amounts are in EUR, before tax.
| Item | Supplier A | Supplier B | Supplier C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unit price per m² | 42.00 | 39.50 | 44.00 |
| Material, 66.24 m² | 2,782.08 | 2,616.48 | 2,914.56 |
| Delivery | 180.00 | 420.00 | 0.00 |
| Landed cost | 2,962.08 | 3,036.48 | 2,914.56 |
| Lead time | 3 weeks | 7 weeks | 2 weeks, in stock |
| Payment terms | 50% advance | 100% prepayment | 30% advance |
Supplier B has the lowest price per m² but the highest landed cost, the longest lead time and the heaviest prepayment. Supplier C looks most expensive per m² and is the best offer on every other line.
Compare the terms that price does not show
After landed cost, compare the conditions that change risk and schedule. Put them in the same table as the prices so nothing stays in an email thread.
| Term | Why it matters | What to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Lead time | Defines the latest order date and the risk of delay | Production or stock time, shipping time, and whether the date is confirmed in writing |
| Price validity | An expired quote may be repriced | Number of days the price is held |
| Payment terms | Advances tie up your cash and the client's | Advance percentage, due date of the balance, payment before or after shipment |
| Batch and shade | Tiles, stone, wallpaper and fabrics vary between batches | Whether the full quantity comes from one batch |
| Scope | Measurement, assembly and removal of packaging are often excluded | A line-by-line list of what is and is not included |
| Damage and returns | Decides who pays when goods arrive broken or wrong | Inspection period, claim procedure, return conditions for unused material |
| Tolerances | Custom joinery and stone differ in accuracy | Dimensional tolerance and who is responsible for site measurements |
Turn lead time into an order date
Work backwards from the site schedule: required date on site minus lead time minus a buffer for delay equals the latest order date. If tiling starts in week 12, lead time is 7 weeks and you keep a one-week buffer, the order must be placed by week 4. A cheaper offer that forces you to order a month earlier may cost more than it saves, because the money is committed sooner and a delay affects every trade after it. The procurement timeline approach follows the same logic for the whole project.
Score the offers and decide
- Remove offers that fail a must-have. Wrong finish, no confirmed lead time or a delivery date after the site deadline all disqualify an offer, whatever the price.
- Rank the rest by landed cost. Use the table, not the unit price.
- Weigh the gap against the risk. If two offers are close in cost, prefer the one with the shorter lead time, the smaller advance and the clearer scope.
- Go back to the top two. Ask them to confirm open points in writing. This is also the moment to ask for a better price on a larger or consolidated order, or for a smaller advance.
- Record the decision. Note the chosen supplier, the reason, the quote number and date, and the price validity, so the choice can be explained to the client later.
Final check before you accept
- The quote matches the latest specification and quantity
- The delivery date is written, not promised verbally
- Advance and balance dates are known and fit the project cash flow
- The price is still valid on the day you confirm
- Every rejected supplier has been told the decision
How to do it in ArchiBoard
The estimates section keeps competing offers, supplier quotes and payment terms next to the item they belong to. Supplier contacts and history are described in the catalog, wishlist and suppliers help chapter.
- Open the project and go to Estimates. Open the item in "Item details" and click "Add analog". Add the competing offer with "Add by URL", "Choose from wishlist" or "Select from catalog". It appears as a branch under the main product.
- To load a supplier's quote as a file, go to Estimates and click "Import". Upload the quote, enable "This is a supplier quote" and fill in "Quote no." and "Quote date".
- To attach a quote to an item that already exists, open "Vendor & payment" and use "Supplier quote". The quote total becomes the purchase price and the client price does not change. "Open PDF" shows the quote breakdown.
- In "Vendor & payment", select the supplier, set "Supplier payment" (tick "This is an advance" if you pay in parts) and enter the planned date under "Dates: delivery and installation".
- Switch the estimate to "Economics" mode to see procurement, markup and profit for the chosen offer.
- Open Suppliers and check the "Reschedules" column. It shows how often a supplier has moved delivery dates and by how many days on average.
- To show the client options, use "Export to PDF" and enable alternatives. They appear under the main item with the label "Alternative option".
FAQ
How many suppliers should I ask for a quote?
Three is usually enough for standard items: it shows the market range without turning the comparison into a project of its own. For expensive custom pieces, ask two or three suppliers who can really make the item. More offers only help if each one is based on the same brief and can be reviewed carefully.
Should I always choose the cheapest quote?
No. Compare landed cost first, then lead time, payment terms and scope. A lower price often hides separate delivery fees, a long production time or a large advance. If the gap between two offers is small, choose the one with the lower delay risk and the clearer written conditions.
How do I compare quotes in different currencies?
Convert every offer to the project currency using one rate and one date, and record that rate. Check that all prices are either before or after tax. Also look at the payment currency: if you pay in a currency other than the quote's, the rate can change between quote and payment, so keep a small allowance.
How do I compare a custom-made item with a catalog item?
List what each price includes: materials, finish, measurement, installation, packaging and delivery. Then compare lead time and the cost of a mistake, because custom work is hard to return. Where the specifications are not identical, compare landed cost and risk separately and note the differences for the client.
What if a supplier will not give a fixed lead time?
Ask for a range and the conditions behind it: stock status, production queue, shipping method. Treat the upper end of the range as the planning date and add a buffer. If the supplier cannot commit to any date, record it as a risk. Prefer an offer with a confirmed date when prices are close.